Complete Idiot’s Guide to Letters of Recommendation written by an idiot
Whom do I ask?
Ask professors who know you and your work well.
Preferably these people will be professors in your discipline.
There are some fields in which a letter from a work or internship supervisor
might be appropriate.
When do I ask?
Ideally two months before the recommendation is due. Professors are
busy people and often have multiple requests from students to write letters. You
want to give them sufficient lead time.
There are times when two month’s notice is not possible. Still
ask, but acknowledge that it is short notice and don’t take it personally
if they can’t commit.
Plan to remind them again as the due date approaches.
What do I say?
Understand that you are not the first student to ever request a letter
of recommendation. While you want to be prepared and sound like you
have somewhat of a clue, don’t fret unnecessarily about asking.
You want to find out if they can write you a STRONG letter of recommendation. A
lukewarm, generic letter of recommendation can damage your application. It’s
better to have a professor tell you now that he or she can’t write
you a strong letter and you suffer a moment of embarrassment than it is to
have them halfheartedly recommend you to the committee later on.
Ideally, make an appointment to meet with the recommender to talk about
your graduate school plans, research plans, etc., and to fill them in on
any personal information you might want them to include. You’d
be surprised how a 15-30 minute conversation can translate into a more detailed,
comprehensive and positive recommendation.
Thank them for agreeing to write a letter.
Ask them if they want a reminder closer to the due date. And if so,
what format do they prefer (i.e., you call them, e-mail them, leave a note
in their box, talk in person). And if they don’t want a reminder,
remind them gently anyway.
What information do I provide?
Program name, school name and deadlines. You could
compile this information in a table similar to the sample below.
Institution
Program
Website
Due date
Specific form
Mail directly
On-line
Give to me
U of Iowa
Ph.D. American Studies
www.
Dec. 1
enclosed
yes
yes
Notes
Marquette
M.A. Family and Marriage Counseling
www.
Dec. 15
yes
yes
Notes
Program information. Printed information about each
program (some faculty will read this and tailor your letter accordingly). Be
selective, as faculty do not have time to wade through irrelevant information.
Recommendation forms. Many programs/colleges provide
their own unique form that they expect the faculty to complete, usually along
with a letter; others have no specific form and merely request a letter. Make
sure you complete the information you are responsible for before giving the
form to your professor. It is inconsiderate to make them fill out your
name, the program to which you are applying, etc. Many programs give
the recommender the option of submitting the recommendation on-line
and might even e-mail the professor to request a recommendation after your
application has been completed. A small but growing number of programs require that
recommendations be submitted on-line. If the graduate school gives
you a choice, give your recommenders the same choice.
Addressed (double check the address for accuracy) and stamped envelopes for
those letters that need to be mailed directly to the program.
Website info for recommendations that will be submitted
electronically.
Envelopes (no stamp or address) for those letters to be
returned to and mailed by you. (NOTE: If a professor hands you
the envelope, look for a signature across the seal; if there isn’t
one, ask for one as most schools require it.)
Resume/C.V. If you do not have a resume
or C.V., at least make a list of past and current employment, honors and
awards, activities and organizational involvement, international travel experiences,
GPA, etc.
Personal Statement. If your statement hasn’t
been drafted yet, at least jot down some notes about why you selected each
program, why you choose your field of study, what your future goals are and
any other pertinent personal information you think they should be aware of. Sometimes
it’s easier to have the recommender explain a low grade or personal
circumstances than to explain them yourself. Of course you both can
and maybe should talk about it. It’s helpful if recommenders
point out that you are first-generation, low-income and/or underrepresented,
a refugee, the sole bread winner in your family, etc.
PLACE ALL OF THE ABOVE IN A LARGE ENVELOPE so they don’t
have to keep track of separate pieces of paper. Put your name on the
envelope. It’s helpful to write the name of each school and the
due date in marker on the outside of the envelope for quick reference.
How do I present the information?
Professionally: neat and complete. Naturally a professor is
going to appreciate and have a positive affect towards you (which will come
out in the letter) if your presentation is professional. In other words,
you are showing them that you have put time and effort into this and that
you respect their time.
Should I waive my right to read the recommendation?
Yes. Then letter writers feel free to say what they want to say. If
you are worried someone will say something bad about you, you probably shouldn’t
have him/her as a recommender. Some professors will hand you a copy
of their letter—read it, feel good about yourself, and take it out
from time to time when you question your ability.
How do I get the recommendations in on time?
Hound professors gently. You might send an e-mail reminder a few
weeks in advance and then a week before. Some professors will do the
letter right away, others will push the deadline. It is your responsibility
to make sure that the letters are received by the deadline.
How can I show gratitude to my recommenders?
Get accepted into graduate school.
Thank them formally (a card is nice).
Copyright
2008. Augsburg College. All rights reserved.